Only the Best for Your Home!

Wood Floor Stain Colors | How to Choose the Right Stain for Hardwood Floors

One of the biggest questions we get here at OC Flooring. when it comes to staining floors is: Should I get my floors stained and if so, what color should I go with?

Stain Color for Wood Floors: DuraSeal Stain Colors & Bona Natural Seal

Hardwood floors are one of the best features a home can have. They’re classic, durable, and beautiful. But after years of use, they can start to look dull or simply not match your style anymore. That’s where staining comes in.

At OC Flooring, one of the biggest questions we hear is:

👉 “What stain color should I choose for my wood floors?”

It’s a big decision — the right color can completely change the look of your home. Don’t worry though, we’ll walk you through it step by step.

OC Flooring Stain samples Seattle 2025

Choosing the stain color for wood floors comes down to your lighting, wood species, and style. In this guide we compare popular DuraSeal stain colors and show when Bona Natural Seal on red oak or Bona Natural Seal on white oak is the better pick.

What Does It Mean to “Stain” Wood Floors?

Staining is simply adding color to your hardwood floors after they’ve been sanded but before the protective finish is applied.
  • Staining = color (light, dark, or something in between).
  • Finishing = protection (clear coats that keep floors strong and shiny).

Not all wood needs stain. Exotic woods like walnut, cherry, or mahogany look great natural. But if you have oak, ash, or pine, stain gives you tons of design options.

Stain samples VS Clear coats

Light vs. Dark Stains – Which Is Better?

There’s no right or wrong — just what fits your home and lifestyle. Here’s the breakdown:

🌤 Light Stains

  • Make rooms look brighter and bigger
  • Great at hiding dust and pet hair
  • Perfect for modern, open spaces
One downside: light stains can sometimes show water spots.

🌑 Dark Stains

  • Rich, warm, and elegant
  • Create a cozy, high-end feel
  • Stunning in large, well-lit rooms

One downside: dark stains show dust and scratches more easily.

💡 Tip: If your home gets lots of sunlight, dark stains look amazing. If your rooms are smaller or darker, go light to open things up.

Light vs Dark stain samples (OC Flooring)

Matching Stain to Your Home’s Style

Your stain color should feel like it “belongs” with your home.
  • Traditional homes → deeper tones like Coffee Brown or Aged Barrel.
  • Modern/minimalist → lighter looks like Bona Natural Seal on red oak.
  • Farmhouse or transitional → warm mid-tones like Chestnut or Gunstock.

Bona Natural Seal on white oak — neutral and modern

Bona Natural Seal on white oak keeps a clean, natural look with less warmth than red oak. If you want that “freshly sanded” Scandinavian vibe without going gray, this is a great choice.

Stain Color for Wood Floors: DuraSeal Stain Colors

We install and refinish with DuraSeal every week. The DuraSeal stain colors most Seattle-area homeowners choose are Chestnut (warm mid-tone), Coffee Brown (rich, classic), and Aged Barrel (deep modern brown). These colors work on both red oak and white oak and are easy to live with.

Our Clients’ Favorite Stain Colors

Here are some tried-and-true winners we see homeowners fall in love with:
  • DuraSeal Chestnut (White Oak) – Warm and versatile.
  • Bona Natural Seal (Red Oak) – Keeps things light and natural.
  • DuraSeal Aged Barrel (Red Oak) – A bold, dramatic brown.
  • DuraSeal Coffee Brown (Red Oak) – Rich and timeless.
  • DuraSeal Rustic Beige (Ash) – Perfect for a modern vibe.
  • Bona IntenseSeal (Maple or White Oak) – Natural clarity with brightness.

Our Clients’ Favorite Stain Colors

Here are some tried-and-true winners homeowners love:

DuraSeal Chestnut on White Oak
DuraSeal Chestnut (White Oak)

DuraSeal Chestnut.

Bona Natural Seal on Red Oak
Bona Natural Seal (Red Oak)

Bona Natural Seal.

DuraSeal Aged Barrel on Red Oak
DuraSeal Aged Barrel (Red Oak)

DuraSeal Aged Barrel.

DuraSeal Coffee Brown on Red Oak
DuraSeal Coffee Brown (Red Oak)

DuraSeal Coffee Brown.

DuraSeal Rustic Beige on Ash
DuraSeal Rustic Beige (Ash)

DuraSeal Rustic Beige.

Bona IntenseSeal on Maple or White Oak
Bona IntenseSeal (Maple or White Oak)

Bona IntenseSeal.

Choosing stain colors for wood floors
OC FLOORING Samples

Prefinished vs. Site-Finished Floors

A lot of homeowners ask: “Do I need to stain my floors if they’re prefinished hardwood?”

Here’s the quick answer:

  • Prefinished hardwood floors come from the factory with stain and finish already applied. They’re strong, easy to install, and usually have a tough wear layer (sometimes with aluminum oxide) to stand up to high-traffic areas.
  • Site-finished hardwood floors are stained after installation. This lets you pick your exact stain color and gives a smooth, seamless look.

What about engineered wood flooring?

Yes, engineered hardwood can often be refinished — but it depends on the top layer’s thickness. If it’s thick enough, we can sand and refinish it just like solid wood. Thin layers may only allow light touch-ups.

👉 That’s why it’s best to have a pro check before planning a refinishing project.

Why Testing Is So Important

Here’s the tricky part: the same stain color looks totally different on different woods.
  • White oak absorbs stain one way.
  • Red oak looks completely different with the same color.

That’s why we always test samples directly on your floors during your free estimate. You’ll see how each option looks in your home, under your lighting.

How we sand the floor and finish it

Before color, we sand the floor to bare wood, vacuum, and prep for an even stain.

  1. Stain: We apply DuraSeal Quick Coat in your chosen tone for fast, consistent color.
  2. Sealer: A first coat of Bona sealer (Bona IntenseSeal or Bona Natural Seal) locks in the look.
  3. Topcoats: Two coats of Bona Traffic HD (traffic hd) waterborne floor finish for high-traffic durability and low odor.

Red oak floors vs. white oak

On red oak floors, many homeowners want to calm warm/orange tones. We can test Bona Red Out (often shortened to “bona red”) before staining, or keep things airy with Bona Natural Seal on red oak. For a creamier neutral, choose Bona Natural Seal on white oak.

Wood Floor Stain — Real FAQs

What stain color for wood floors works best in darker rooms?
Go lighter. The right stain color for wood floors in low-light spaces is a pale or natural tone—try Bona Natural Seal on white oak to keep rooms open and bright.
Are gray wood floors out of style now?
Cool gray floors are fading. Homeowners are moving toward natural oak and warm mid-tones, with some choosing deep, moody browns for contrast. If you want a modern but timeless look, keep it natural or choose balanced mid-browns.
Do dark floors show more dust and scratches than light floors?
Yes—dark stains tend to highlight dust, pet hair, and fine scratches. Light floors usually hide day-to-day mess better, which is handy for busy homes and high-traffic areas.
Bona Natural Seal on red oak vs. white oak — what’s the difference?
Bona Natural Seal on red oak keeps the floor light while softening red undertones. On white oak, it looks more neutral/creamy and very “freshly sanded.” Both are great if you want a clean, natural look without going gray.
Which DuraSeal stain colors are reliable go-tos?
Homeowners consistently gravitate to these DuraSeal stain colors: Chestnut (warm mid-tone), Coffee Brown (classic dark), Aged Barrel (deep modern brown), and Gunstock (traditional warmth). Always test on your actual floor.
Can engineered hardwood be refinished?
Often, yes—if the wear layer is thick enough. As a rule of thumb, ~2–4 mm wear layers can sometimes be refinished once or twice; thin veneers may be screen & recoat only. Let a pro confirm before you plan a full sand.
What is “water popping” and do I need it?
Water popping lightly wets sanded wood to open the grain so stain penetrates more evenly and looks deeper—especially on oak. It’s optional but useful when you want richer color or more uniform results.
How do I tone down orange/red on red oak without going gray?
Choose balanced neutrals and test first. Bona Natural Seal on red oak is a popular pick to calm strong warmth while keeping a natural, bright look.
Medium, light, or dark—what ages best?
Trends swing, but medium, natural-leaning tones tend to feel timeless. If you want ultra-low-maintenance, lean lighter; if you want drama and contrast, choose a rich dark and plan for a little extra upkeep.

Maintenance Tips by Color

  • Light stains → easier to maintain, hides dust and scratches.
  • Dark stains → show dust more, but unbeatable for elegance.
  • Prefinished wood flooring → often more durable because of factory finishes, especially in busy homes.

Why Hire Professionals?

DIY staining sounds tempting, but here’s the truth:

  • Sanding mistakes are hard to fix.
  • Stain can go on blotchy without the right technique.
  • Dust control is tough without pro equipment.

At OC Flooring, we use premium DuraSeal and Bona products, apply stains evenly, and give you a flawless finish that lasts. Plus, we back our work with a one-year warranty.

How Much Does Staining Cost?

It depends on:

  • The size of your project
  • Whether your floors are solid or engineered
  • How many coats are needed

The good news? We’ll give you a free, detailed estimate so you’ll know the exact cost before we start.

Ready to Pick Your Perfect Stain?

Choosing a stain doesn’t have to be stressful. With our help, you’ll love the results — whether you want a light, airy vibe or a dark, dramatic style.

📞 Call 425-595-1079 or email info.ocflooring@gmail.com to schedule your free in-home estimate today.

We proudly refinish hardwood floors in Lynnwood, Mill Creek, Edmonds, Shoreline, and Bothell, WA.

⭐ Rated 4.8/5 stars by 121 happy clients.

Final Thoughts

Your wood floor stain color sets the tone for your entire home. Whether you’re looking at solid hardwood flooring, engineered wood, or prefinished hardwood floors, the right stain will bring out the best in your space.
At OC Flooring, we make the process easy, stress-free, and — most importantly — beautiful. Let’s make your floors something you’re proud to show off.

Oleg Chaikovskyi headshot
Oleg Chaikovskyi
Owner of OC Flooring
Bellevue, WA

Schedule Instantly – Get Your Home Estimate Without the Wait!

More Similar Blog Posts