"Should I Refinish or Replace My Floor? A Homeowner's Guide"

Hello there, dear homeowners! Are you standing on your wood floor and wondering whether it's time for a change? It's a common crossroads many of us face: should we breathe new life into our existing wood floors through refinishing, or is it time to start fresh with a brand-new floor? Let's dive into this dilemma and find the best solution for your beloved home!

Understanding the Basics: Refinishing vs. Replacing

First things first, let's break down what each option entails:

  • Refinishing: This process involves sanding down your existing wood floors to remove the old finish, scratches, and stains. After sanding, a new finish is applied, giving your floor a fresh, new look. It's like giving your floor a rejuvenating spa day!
  • Replacing: As you might guess, this means removing your current flooring entirely and installing new wood. It's a bit like giving your home a brand-new pair of shoes.

When to Refinish Your Wood Floors

Refinishing is a fantastic option under certain conditions:

  • Minor Wear and Tear: If your floor's issues are mainly cosmetic, such as small scratches or a dull finish, refinishing can make it look brand new.
  • Budget-Friendly: Generally, refinishing is more cost-effective than replacing. It's a great way to save some pennies while still making a significant impact.
  • Historical Charm: If you live in an older home with original floors, refinishing preserves the wood's history and charm.

When Replacement Might Be the Better Choice

Sometimes, starting anew is the best path:

  • Extensive Damage: If your floors have significant damage, like deep gouges, warped boards, or extensive water damage, replacement might be the way to go.
  • Desire for a Completely New Look: Craving a completely different wood type or color? Replacing gives you the freedom to choose a new style that better matches your current taste.
  • Old Floors with Multiple Refinishings: Floors can only be refinished a certain number of times. If yours have been through this process multiple times, replacement might be necessary.
Home Flooring Renovation

Consider the Age and Condition of Your Floors

The age and condition of your floors are significant factors. Older floors with character can often benefit greatly from refinishing. However, floors that have seen decades of use and multiple refinishings might be better off replaced.

Budget and Time Considerations

  • Budget: Refinishing is generally kinder to your wallet. But remember, investing in new flooring can also add value to your home.
  • Time and Inconvenience: Refinishing can be a quicker process, though it's often quite messy and noisy. Replacement takes longer but can be worth the wait for a brand-new look.

Environmental Impact

Refinishing is more eco-friendly since it reuses existing materials. If you opt for replacement, consider sustainable wood options to keep your home green!

Conclusion: What's Best for Your Home?

Ultimately, the choice between refinishing and replacing your wood floor depends on the floor's current condition, your personal style preferences, budget, and environmental considerations. Both options have their charms and benefits, so weigh your options carefully to make the best decision for your home.

Feeling ready to make a choice? Whether it's refinishing to restore the glory of your current floors or replacing them for a fresh start, your home is about to get a whole lot cozier!

Ready to schedule your free at home estimate?  

We guarantee a detailed, competitive assessment, and customer service you won’t find anywhere else.

Feel free to call at 425-595-1079 or email us to

SERVING: Lynnwood, WA Everett, WA Bothell, WA Mill Creek, WA Marysville, WA Seattle, WA Kirkland, WA Redmond, WA Bellevue, WA Woodinville, WA Edmonds, WA Mukilteo, WA Shoreline, WA
North Bend, WA Renton, WA Sammamish, WA Kenmore, WA Snohomish, WA

Send Us a Message

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.


Mon-Fri: 9am - 5pm
Sat: 10am - 3pm
Sun: Closed

Call Us Now!

(425) 595-1079

Written on
February 17, 2023
by Block

More blog posts